Transcript follows.

Transcript
148, Russa Road,
Calcutta.
26th July 1925.
My dear young Friend,
I like your frank and sincere letter for which I thank you.
You seem to have taken it for granted that I hate the British. What makes you think so? I have hundreds of friends among the British people. I cannot love the Mussalmans and for that matter the Hindus if I hate the British. My love is not an exclusive affair. If I hate the British today, I would have to hate the Mohammedans tomorrow and the Hindus the day after. But what I do detest is the system of government that the British have set up in my country. It has almost brought the economic and moral ruin of the people of India. But just as I love my wife and children, in spite of their faults which are many, I love also the British in spite of the bad system for which they have unfortunately made themselves responsible. That love which is blind is no love, that love which shuts its eyes to the faults of loved ones is partial and even dangerous. You must write again if this letter does not satisfy you.
Yours sincerely,
(Signed, 'MKGandhi')
7 comments:
Concrete reasoning. Really good letter.
I'm a fan of Ghandi, but to be honest his first argument is a failing one. How many times have we heard "I can't be racist/homophobic/whatever because I have a black/gay/whatever friend." Argument. It doesn't hold water. People maintain different views towards individuals than they do ethnic groups.
Some people really do deserve the Peace Prize
#2 - Well he does say "I don't hate the British, I just hate their government." The argument you mention is indeed a fallacy, but it doesn't mean someone who employs it is automatically a bigot.
Your blog is fascinating. I don't know how you get so many of these letters! They are just great to read.
I have an award for you here:
http://www.newjerseymemories.com/2010/07/my-first-award.html
I would love to read Fred Campbell's reply!
Actually Gandhi never got the Peace Prize... The story of why he didn't makes for some really interesting history
Post a Comment
Should this post be older than 10 days, your comment will be moderated.
Thanks!