Recent Letters

Thursday, 15 July 2010

I'm afraid I thought this one as dire as its title

In May of 1974, after reading through a pilot script written by John Cleese and his then-wife, Connie Booth, a clearly unimpressed 'comedy script editor' by the name of Ian Main sent the following memo to BBC Television's Head of Comedy and Light Entertainment. Luckily for the general population, and thanks in no small part to the persistence of Cleese and Booth, Main's opinion was ultimately ignored by his superiors and a year later the script had evolved into a programme which to this day is considered one of the funniest ever to grace our screens. The show was Fawlty Towers.

Speaking in 2009, John Cleese said of this very memo, "It just shows you people have no idea what they are doing."

Transcript follows. Enormous thanks to Sam Ward for providing the image.



Transcript
From: Comedy Script Editor, Light Entertainment, Television
Room No. & Building: 4009 TC
Tel. Ext.: 2900
date: 29.5.1974.

Subject: "FAWLTY TOWERS" BY JOHN CLEESE & CONNIE BOOTH
To: H.C.L.E.

I'm afraid I thought this one as dire as its title.

It's a kind of "Prince of Denmark" of the hotel world. A collection of cliches and stock characters which I can't see being anything but a disaster.

(Signed, 'I.M.')

(Ian Main)

CF

13 comments:

Patti said...

I LOVE FAWLTY TOWERS!!

Anonymous said...

Don't mention the war!

spiralise said...

How many great comedies, series, films, etc. never got past people like this?

We all know how many dull ones did get the green light.

Anonymous said...

Anyone know what happened to Ian Main? What a twit.

mtconleyuk said...

Not just a twit, but a great twit!

Anonymous said...

Don't mind Ian, he's probably from Barcelona...

(apologies in advance to the great city of Barcelona)

vulpisfoxfire said...

Que? ;-)

Anonymous said...

Is this a piece of your brain?

Anonymous said...

I'm going to stick up for Ian Main here.

We remember that 'Fawlty Towers' is a classic now but we forget that it's a classic because of the great comic acting of Cleese. The script really is just a collection of stock characters - but Cleese's genius makes it work.

If you were passed the script without having seen a single episode you would probably have the same reaction. If you don't believe me - check out the American remake. The same script but different actors. It was a disaster and (thankfully) instantly forgotten.

Hindsight is 20:20

About me: said...

Reminds me of the infamous "guitar music will never last" rejection the Beatles got from a record company.

Anonymous said...

The thing is, Mr. Main was exactly correct. It WAS a collection of cliches and stock characters; however, they were brilliant and funny. History is pocked with this kind of irony.

Anonymous said...

In a way, he was right: they were all more or less stock characters. It's what they did with those characters that made it so hilarious.

Somebody mentioned "Don't mention the war!" and it CRACKED ME UP all over again... HAAHAAHAAHAHA!

Cleese also co-wrote a psychology book called "how to survive your family" which has long been on my to-read list. It's supposed to be hilarious, too.

pethounds said...

I think Ian Main ended up in Australia as a secondary school teacher. At least, I suspect that's the same humorless and pedantic Mr Main I had for English all those years.

Post a Comment

Should this post be older than 10 days, your comment will be moderated.

Thanks!