Recent Letters

Friday, 30 April 2010

My position concerning God is that of an agnostic

In 1954, in a much-debated letter we featured here back in October, Einstein wrote, 'The word God is for me nothing more than the expression and product of human weakness, the Bible a collection of honorable, but still purely primitive, legends which are nevertheless pretty childish'. Today we have another of Einstein's letters, again concerning religion and equally as outspoken, but written four years previous - in 1950 - to a Morton Berkowitz.

Transcript follows.



Transcript
October 25, 1950

Mr. Morton Berkowitz
365 New York Ave.
Brooklyn N.Y.

Dear Mr. Berkowitz:

I felt very grateful receiving your kind letter of October 24th. Such utterances are the finest reward for an author.

My position concerning God is that of an agnostic. I am convinced that vivid consciousness of the primary importance of moral principles for the betterment and enoblement of life does not need the idea of a law-giver, especially a law-giver who works on the basis of reward and punishment

I am sending you under separate cover two books of mine containing occasional writings where you will find more about this subject.

Sincerely yours,

(Signed, 'A. Einstein.')

Albert Einstein.

11 comments:

Anonymous said...

I wish we knew which books he sent him!

Anonymous said...

Probably the old and new testament... to show how funny they are! :) Adam and Eve had 2 boys, i rest my case. :)

Eric

Ummie said...

I just happened to stumble upon this blog.
Great effort!!!

Anonymous said...

Ummm...Anonymous, Eric: Adam and Even did not only have 2 boys. Adam and Eve had Cain (Genesis 4:1), Abel (Genesis 4:2), Seth (Genesis 4:25), and "many other sons AND DAUGHTERS" (Genesis 5:4).

Anonymous said...

Ah, so they were incestuous, but heterosexual, so it's OK. Gotcha.

Anonymous said...

Obviously "incest" was the case. From our modern perspective, this sounds horrible. But they were the only people. Who else could they procreate with? The world was new...genetic anomalies had not developed yet. Not sure why this is such an "issue" for people. No matter what one believes about origins, obviously some odd relationships must have occurred in order for humanity to initially increase in population.

Anonymous said...

ok so there were only adam ,eve and their sons and DAUGHTERS...but after cain have killed abel he fears that some other people could kill him and he moves to another city and get married and god puts a mark on him so that the other people will know that they can not kill him.... where the hell all this other people came from????????

Anonymous said...

Great question. No easy answers. Some thoughts: The entire book of Genesis covers a huge time span, and only certain key events are highlighted. Sometimes there is a long jump in time between highlighted events. We are not told everything that happened in between. Possible answers to who these other people were that Cain feared?...Maybe he feared unmentioned descendants of Adam and Eve. People had longer life expectancies back then, and population can expand VERY rapidly regardless. Perhaps Abel had children with his wife, and Cain was concerned about nephews, great nephews (etc) that had moved off to another area. Adam & Eve’s many other children may have wanted to take vengeance on Cain. With rapid population expansion, any number of descendants could have wanted to kill him for what he did to "grandpa Abel".

Anonymous said...

people had LONGER life expectancies back then?

Jamie said...

Biblical quibbling aside... I saved a copy of the letter for myself because that second paragraph is pure poetry.

foster said...

where the hell all this other people came from???????? - Anonymous, 14 May, 18:36

Easy: Monkeys. Led directly to catholicism.

Post a Comment

Should this post be older than 10 days, your comment will be moderated.

Thanks!